By Chao Katie Nov 17, 2026

Should You Sell Now? A Financial Gut Check for Metro Vancouver Homeowners

If you bought in the last few years, your home may be worth less today than what you paid for it. That's hard to hear, but it's only one part of the decision.

Metro Vancouver is in a buyer's market. Prices have been sliding for more than a year, there are plenty of homes to choose from, and buyers are taking their time. If you're thinking about selling, the price you paid is probably the first thing on your mind.

I'd start with a different question: will selling now get me closer to where I want to be?

Here's how I'd work through it before picking a listing date.

Question 1: What will you actually walk away with?

Start here, not with the price you paid. What matters is how much ends up in your account after completion, once the mortgage and selling costs are paid.

Get these numbers before you decide anything:

  • A realistic sale price, based on what has actually sold nearby, not the asking price down the street
  • Your exact mortgage payout, including any prepayment penalty. Ask your lender for it in writing. On a fixed rate mortgage, the penalty can be a lot bigger than people expect.
  • Any line of credit secured against the home
  • Commission plus GST
  • Legal or notary fees
  • Moving costs, plus any repairs or prep before listing

Here's what that can look like. These are example numbers only.

Item

Amount

Realistic sale price

$1,850,000

Mortgage payout

-$1,300,000

Prepayment penalty

-$15,000

Commission plus GST

-$55,000

Legal fees

-$2,000

Moving and prep

-$8,000

Estimated net to you

$470,000

Then ask yourself: is that enough for your next step? If you're buying again, that money is your down payment and your cushion. If it doesn't cover what's next, selling now may not help.

If your net comes out close to zero, or below it, stop here. Talk to your lender and your accountant before going any further.

Question 2: You paid more than it's worth today. Now what?

This part is hard. You can't get back the difference between what you paid and what the home is worth today. Buyers won't pay more because of it either. They don't know what you paid.

What you're doing next matters more. Many sellers are also buying, and they're buying in the same slow market.

If you're moving up, a slow market can work in your favour. Say both homes dropped about 10%:


Then

Now

Your current home

$2,050,000

$1,850,000

The home you want

$2,900,000

$2,600,000

The gap you need to cover

$850,000

$750,000

On paper, you're down $200,000. But the difference between your home and the next one shrank by $100,000, so you'd have $100,000 less to finance. (These are example numbers, not a forecast.)

If you're downsizing, it usually runs the other way. You're selling the bigger home in a slow market, and the smaller home you're buying probably hasn't dropped as much in dollars. If you don't need the cash right away, waiting could be worth a look.

If you're selling and not buying (moving away, renting, cashing out), you lock in today's price. Then the question becomes whether you need that money now, or whether the cost of holding is the bigger problem.

What about the one buyer who'll pay more? It does happen, even in a slow market. A home with something hard to find, like a view, a big lot, a suite for extended family or a specific school catchment, can matter a lot more to one buyer than to everyone else. But you can't count on that buyer, and you can't price for them. Price for the market, prepare the home well and get it in front of as many people as possible. If that buyer is out there, that's how they'll find it.

So look at the full move, the sale and the purchase together, not just the loss on your current home.

Question 3: What does staying actually cost you?

Selling for less than you paid is painful. Keeping the home costs money too, and it's easy to leave that out of the math.

Add up what the home costs you every month: mortgage, property tax, insurance, strata fees, any special levies, and regular maintenance. Then ask yourself:

  • When does your mortgage renew? The Bank of Canada raised rates on October 28, its first increase in three years, and said more increases could be needed. Your next payment may not look like your current one. Ask your mortgage broker for the actual number.
  • Does the home still fit your life? A house that's too big, too far or too expensive to run is a cost even when the market is flat.
  • If it's a strata property, what's in the depreciation report? A major repair coming up can mean a special levy. And buyers will read the same documents you do.

If you can comfortably afford the home and nothing is pushing you to move, you don't have to sell into this market.

Question 4: Do you have to sell, or do you want to?

Be honest with yourself here. The answer changes the plan.

Have to sell: a job move, a separation, an estate, a health change, payments that no longer work. Waiting for the market to turn usually isn't an option. The plan becomes: price it right from day one, prepare it well, and negotiate carefully. In a market like this, an overpriced home sits, and a home that sits usually ends up selling for less than one priced well at the start.

Want to sell: more space, a different school catchment, closer to family, simplifying. You have choices. Sell now, wait, or decide on the price you'd need and only move if the market gets you there.

Both are good reasons to sell. The plan for each one looks different.

Tax points to check before you list

I'm not an accountant, and this is general information, not tax advice. But these are worth a conversation before you sign anything.

  • A loss on your principal residence isn't deductible. Your home is personal-use property for tax purposes, so a loss on it can't reduce your income or offset other gains. 
  • An investment property can be treated differently. A loss on a rental may count as a capital loss. Have your accountant confirm how it applies to you.
  • Owned it less than two years? Check the BC home flipping tax. It applies to profit on a BC property, presale contracts included, sold within 730 days of buying. The rate is 20% in the first 365 days and drops to zero at 730 days. There are exemptions for certain life events, such as separation, death, illness, job relocation or involuntary job loss, but some require filing a return. Selling at a loss may mean no profit to tax, but confirm it. 

Options besides selling now

Selling isn't the only move. Depending on your numbers:

  • Wait. If carrying the home is comfortable, revisit in six or twelve months with fresh numbers.
  • Rent it out. This can work if the rent covers most of your costs. Be realistic about the costs: vacancy, maintenance, taxes, strata rental bylaws. And ask your accountant first, because turning your home into a rental has tax consequences. Being a landlord is also a job.
  • Buy first or sell first, on purpose. With less competition, some sellers may be more open to a subject to sale clause or a longer completion. That can take some of the timing risk off you.
  • Fix the cash flow instead of the house. If the real issue is the monthly payment, a mortgage broker may have options that don't involve selling.

Whichever way you go, base it on your numbers, not on how the market feels this month.

So, should you sell?

The price you paid matters less than three things: what you'll net, what you're doing next, and what it costs to wait.

If selling now gets you closer to where you want to be, a slow market isn't a reason to hold off. If it doesn't, waiting is a perfectly reasonable choice.

If you'd like to see your own numbers, send me an email. I'll put together a realistic picture of what your home would sell for today and what you'd actually walk away with.

Share this article